Sourcing Strategies
•
Understanding the importance of control in phone conversations
Why Control Matters in Recruiter-Candidate Calls
When recruiters pick up the phone to speak with candidates, maintaining control is more than just keeping the conversation on track. It’s about making the most of the limited time available, ensuring that both the recruiter and the candidate get what they need from the call. In today’s fast-paced recruitment process, every phone call is a chance to represent the company, clarify the job role, and assess if the candidate is a good fit for the hiring team.
Recruiters often juggle multiple calls a day, each with its own set of expectations and challenges. Without a clear structure, calls can drift off-topic, wasting valuable time for both parties. This is especially true when dealing with passive candidates or those who may not be actively searching for a new job. A recruiter’s ability to guide the conversation helps keep the hiring process efficient and focused on the company’s needs.
- Time management: Calls that run too long or lose focus can delay the recruitment process and frustrate both recruiters and hiring managers.
- Consistent messaging: Maintaining control ensures that every candidate hears a clear, accurate description of the job and the company job culture.
- Building trust: Candidates appreciate when recruiters respect their time and privacy policy, which can help build rapport and encourage passive talent to engage further.
Recruiters who maintain control during calls are better equipped to gather the information hiring teams need, answer candidate questions, and move the process forward. This is especially important when sourcing potential candidates for hard-to-fill roles or when cold calling passive candidates who may not be expecting the outreach.
For a deeper understanding of how direct sourcing is changing the way recruiters connect with candidates, check out this resource on modern approaches to candidate sourcing. This will help you see how control in conversations fits into the bigger picture of recruitment strategy.
Common challenges recruiters face during candidate calls
Why Recruiters Lose Control on Candidate Calls
Phone calls are a core part of the recruitment process, but recruiters often face challenges that can disrupt the flow of a conversation. Maintaining control is essential for making the most of the limited time available, especially when dealing with passive candidates or those unfamiliar with the company job or role. Here are some common hurdles recruiters encounter during candidate calls:
- Unstructured conversations: Without a clear agenda, calls can drift off-topic, wasting valuable time and making it harder to gather the information needed for the hiring process.
- Candidate reluctance: Some candidates, especially passive talent, may be hesitant to share details about their job search or current job title. This can slow down the recruitment process and make it difficult to assess fit.
- Information overload: Candidates sometimes provide too much background or go into unrelated details, making it challenging for recruiters to keep the call focused on the job and company requirements.
- Scheduling conflicts: Not all candidates are ready to talk when the recruiter calls. Finding a good time to talk can be tough, especially when juggling multiple hiring teams and time zones.
- Privacy concerns: Candidates may worry about sharing personal information over the phone, especially if they are currently employed. This can limit open communication and slow down moving forward in the hiring process.
- External distractions: Both recruiters and candidates may be interrupted by emails, notifications, or background noise, which can disrupt the flow of the phone call.
Recruiters also need to balance the expectations of hiring managers and the hiring team, ensuring that every call is productive and aligned with the company’s recruitment goals. Cold calling potential candidates or following up on job postings can add another layer of complexity, as not everyone is prepared or willing to engage in a conversation right away.
For more insights into how changes at the executive level can impact candidate sourcing and recruitment, you may find this article on what a new C-suite executive appointment means for candidate sourcing helpful.
Techniques to guide and structure the conversation
Structuring the Conversation for Maximum Impact
Recruiters know that a well-structured phone call can make all the difference in the recruitment process. When you’re reaching out to potential candidates—especially passive talent who may not be actively job searching—having a clear plan helps you stay on track and respect everyone’s time. Here are some practical techniques to guide and structure your calls:- Set the agenda early: At the start of the call, briefly outline what you’d like to cover. For example, mention that you’ll discuss the candidate’s background, the job title and responsibilities, and next steps. This helps manage expectations and keeps the conversation focused.
- Use open and closed questions strategically: Open questions encourage candidates to share more about their experience and motivations. Closed questions help you clarify details quickly, which is especially useful when time is limited.
- Keep the job and company in focus: Tie your questions back to the company job requirements and the hiring team’s needs. This ensures you’re gathering relevant information for the hiring manager and moving forward efficiently.
- Summarize and check understanding: After discussing key points, summarize what you’ve heard and confirm with the candidate. This avoids misunderstandings and shows you’re listening.
- Manage time talk: If a candidate goes off-topic, gently steer the conversation back. For example, "That’s interesting, but let’s get back to your experience with [relevant skill or role]." This keeps the call productive for both sides.
Handling difficult or evasive candidates
Staying Focused When Candidates Dodge Questions
Recruiters often encounter candidates who avoid direct answers or steer the conversation off track. This can happen for many reasons—nervousness, lack of preparation, or even a desire to hide gaps in their job history. Whatever the reason, it’s important for recruiters to keep the call productive and respectful of everyone’s time.- Set clear expectations: At the start of the phone call, explain the structure and purpose. Let the candidate know you’ll be covering specific topics related to the job and company. This helps reduce surprises and keeps the conversation focused.
- Redirect politely: If a candidate goes off-topic or avoids a question, gently bring them back. For example, "That’s interesting, but I’d like to understand more about your experience with [job title or skill]." This shows you value their input but need to cover key points for the hiring process.
- Use closed questions: Open-ended questions can sometimes lead to long, unfocused answers. If you notice this, switch to yes/no or specific questions to get the information you need.
- Manage time: Keep an eye on the clock. If a candidate spends too long on one topic, remind them of the time and the need to cover other areas. This is especially important when you have multiple phone calls scheduled or need to report back to the hiring manager or team.
Dealing with Evasive or Defensive Responses
Some candidates may become defensive when asked about gaps in employment, reasons for leaving a job, or their interest in the company job. Here’s how recruiters can handle these situations:- Stay neutral and empathetic: Use a calm, non-judgmental tone. Let candidates know that everyone’s job search is unique and that you’re just gathering information to help the hiring team make informed decisions.
- Reframe the question: If a candidate is hesitant, try rephrasing. For example, "Can you share what you learned during your time away from work?" This can help them open up and provide useful insights for the recruitment process.
- Offer privacy assurance: Remind candidates that their information is handled according to your company’s privacy policy. This can build trust and encourage more honest answers, especially when discussing sensitive topics.
When to Move Forward or End the Call
Not every phone conversation will go smoothly. If a candidate remains evasive or uncooperative despite your best efforts, it may be time to wrap up. Politely explain that you need certain information to move forward in the hiring process. If they’re not ready to share, suggest they email you later or reconnect when they’re prepared to discuss the role in more detail. This approach respects both your time and theirs, and keeps the recruitment process efficient for all parties involved. Remember, good recruiters balance persistence with empathy. Handling difficult calls well will help you identify the best potential candidates for your hiring teams, even when the conversation gets tough.Balancing control with building rapport
Finding the Right Balance Between Authority and Connection
Recruiters often walk a fine line during phone calls. On one hand, you need to keep the conversation on track and gather the information needed for the hiring process. On the other, building trust and rapport with candidates is essential for a positive recruitment experience. Striking this balance is key to successful candidate sourcing and moving forward in the hiring process. Recruiters who focus only on control can come across as rigid or impersonal. This may discourage passive candidates or even active job seekers from engaging further. At the same time, letting the candidate lead the call can result in missed information or wasted time, which is not ideal for busy hiring teams or hiring managers. Here are some practical ways to maintain control while still building a good relationship:- Set expectations early: At the start of the phone call, briefly outline what will be discussed and how much time you have. This helps candidates feel comfortable and shows respect for their time.
- Use active listening: Show genuine interest in the candidate’s job search, experience, and career goals. People respond well when they feel heard, making it easier to guide the conversation back to the job or company when needed.
- Ask open-ended questions: Encourage candidates to share details about their current role, skills, and what they’re looking for. This approach helps you gather insights while keeping the call structured.
- Share relevant information: Give candidates a glimpse into the company job, team culture, or hiring manager expectations. This builds trust and keeps the conversation two-sided, not just an interrogation.
- Be transparent about next steps: Let candidates know what will happen after the call, whether it’s an interview, an email follow-up, or feedback from the hiring team. This clarity reassures candidates and keeps the recruitment process moving forward.
Tools and scripts to support recruiters on calls
Practical Resources for Effective Phone Calls
Recruiters know that staying organized and prepared is key to running productive phone conversations. Having the right tools and scripts on hand can make a real difference in the recruitment process, especially when time is limited and the hiring team expects results.- Call Scripts: A well-structured script helps recruiters guide the conversation, ensuring all important topics are covered. Scripts can include prompts for discussing the job title, company job requirements, and next steps in the hiring process. They also help recruiters stay on track when calls go off-topic or when candidates are evasive.
- Note-Taking Tools: Digital tools like applicant tracking systems (ATS) or simple note apps allow recruiters to quickly capture key points during the call. This is especially useful for sharing information with hiring managers or the hiring team after the call.
- Scheduling Software: Tools that automate the process of setting up calls save time and reduce back-and-forth emails. This helps recruiters focus on the conversation itself, not logistics.
- Privacy Policy Templates: Having a clear privacy policy ready to share with potential candidates reassures them about how their data will be handled, building trust from the start.
- Follow-Up Email Templates: After a phone call, a quick follow-up email can confirm next steps, recap the discussion, and keep candidates engaged in the recruitment process.
